Kawakami should be your top priority now. Raise your guts and give her a call!
The Kamoshida and Madarame arcs were my favourite. I think the story takes a dip in quality afterwards and I'm not particularly fond of rest of the characters. PS: Ryuji >>> Yusuke
Talking Sock Big Daddy Boss
Posts : 9250 Joined : 2008-08-11 Age : 32 Location : Down Under
Subject: Re: Persona 5 Fri Jun 30, 2017 1:34 am
Spoiler:
The low point of the story is Akechi turning into the standard deranged woobie antagonist. For a game that gets labeled as "animu," the story doesn't really dip into those tired characterizations and tropes much, but then Akechi goes and undoes it with his woe-is-me bad guy routine, over the top snapped demeanor and all. Screw you Akechi. Go have some pancakes.
Golden Boy Style Icon
Posts : 9301 Joined : 2008-07-31
Subject: Re: Persona 5 Fri Jun 30, 2017 2:32 pm
That part was so bad that I'd actually forgotten about it.
Spoiler:
However, I don't think it's as bad as Morgana and Ryuji's quarrel in September. That one felt so forced and it really pissed me off. It was just an excuse to introduce Haru, a completely irrelevant character plot-wise, and begin the Okumura arc.
SimianWonder Simian D. Wonder
Posts : 6439 Joined : 2008-10-12 Age : 44 Location : Old People's home
Subject: Re: Persona 5 Sun Jul 02, 2017 7:36 am
Ok, so I'm not reading those spoilers.
On a separate note, I just finished the 3rd palace and am now waiting for the change of heart. Firstly, good call on the SP recovery accessory, Chou. I got the highest tier accessory and managed to - by the skin of my teeth - get the entire palace done in a single visit. Recovering 7-10SP per turn is a godsend.
For the most part, the game has been excellent thus far, I've clocked up over 30 hours in ten days but I do just want to touch on a couple of complaints. Firstly, the in-palace stealth. It works fine mostly, but the fact that the camera is then reduced to moving on such a limited plane means that often you are unable to pounce on an enemy who is literally right next to you. It's really frustrating.
Secondly, there's occasionally a bit of a disconnect between in-game character faces and the anime style portraits. For example, Kawakami was having a chat with me about something and while her character model had raised eyebrows and looks somewhat mournful (which fit the tone of the conversation), the portrait looked straight-up angry. It's may seem only a minor thing, but changing the emotion under which a sentence is spoken can completely change its context.
Golden Boy Style Icon
Posts : 9301 Joined : 2008-07-31
Subject: Re: Persona 5 Sun Jul 02, 2017 2:50 pm
Palace 3 took me two days to complete as I didn't know at that point about SP Adhesive 3. It's still my accessory of choice for Joker, Ann, Morgana and Makoto. For Ryuji and Yusuke (almost forgot that I never use him) I prefer the item you get from the last treasure demon because they are primarily physical attackers.
To be fair, I feel kinda bad about Yusuke; it's painfully obvious that he's really weak compared to the others. Atlas must really hate him. - he has the highest STR, but he learns the crappiest skills (his Luck isn't high and critical hits / baton passes don't work on bosses anyway), so he ends up having the second lowest damage output in general - weakest magic attacks since Ryuji learns Elec AND Shock Boost - lower HP and Endurance than Ryuji, requires constant healing considering he has to spend HP to use physical skills + he learns the skill that buffs the team's Agility, which is arguably the least useful buff
Anyway, I think you should spend some time with the Fortuneteller.
SimianWonder Simian D. Wonder
Posts : 6439 Joined : 2008-10-12 Age : 44 Location : Old People's home
Subject: Re: Persona 5 Sun Jul 02, 2017 8:43 pm
Increasing rank with Kawakami offers obvious benefits, even if you still have to fork out 5000 yen each time you want her to make a coffee for you or do the laundry, and the I've only seen the slacking off perks proc once in the entirety of July. Maybe other months will offer more frequent opportunities to make use of those abilities?
Oh, and I meant to ask; what's so great about the fortune teller? I'm up to rank 3 with her, and whilst I appreciate I can use her to generate some more money in the Metaverse I'm struggling to see much tangible use for her other abilities. Improving stats sounds great, but the buff costs 5000 yen and only lasts a day? It seems it only increases your gains by one point in any event and cannot surpass the maximum of 3 points per event. If money was in abundance then it wouldn't be a problem, but I've not yet had more than 150,000 at once, and I had to fork out 100k to start the Confidant any way.
Poor, poor Yusuke. I used him once, then cast him aside as well. Makoto walked straight in to the team (nudging Morgana out because Joker has Kaguya for healing duty) and she's got a freaking motorbike for a persona.
Golden Boy Style Icon
Posts : 9301 Joined : 2008-07-31
Subject: Re: Persona 5 Sun Jul 02, 2017 9:18 pm
Oh no, Simian is a Makoto fanboy!? I find it funny that there is always a "Makoto is the canon waifu" active topic on Gamefaqs. Joking aside, Makoto near the endgame outclasses Morgana in almost every way, but I still prefer the cat.
Kawakami's best ability is the very last one. I'm not going to spoil it for you though. For the fortune teller, you'll have to reach rank 7. The buff she provides affects Joker's relationships with the confidants. It basically gives extra "bond points" turning many of those "I don't my bond will deepen yet" into "I think we will grow closer soon". If you're not following a guide, you'll probably need her to max out the confidants.
SimianWonder Simian D. Wonder
Posts : 6439 Joined : 2008-10-12 Age : 44 Location : Old People's home
Subject: Re: Persona 5 Sun Jul 02, 2017 10:10 pm
Not really a Makoto fanboy as such - I've already gotten Ann to rank 9 and opted to start a romance there: Lovers arcana, right? - but I thought the bike persona was really cool, and wanted to see it more frequently. Thanks for not spoiling anything, but given some of the social stat requirements, I think I'm unlikely to max out all Confidants on 1st play through. From what I can gather, I need max charm just to get Makoto to the next rank, and I'm only half way through her confidant ranks.
What does end-game Morgana offer over and above Makoto, or can you not discuss without listing possible spoilers?
Golden Boy Style Icon
Posts : 9301 Joined : 2008-07-31
Subject: Re: Persona 5 Mon Jul 03, 2017 12:05 am
Well, if you don't consider the skills they have yet to learn as spoilers, go ahead and read it.
Spoiler:
Makoto learns Mediarahan and Energy Shower and cures any other ailment or KOs using items. She also learns the defence buff, has lots of SP (not as many as Morgana equipped with his best slingshot though), she is weak to a rare element and her ultimate gun is mind-bogglingly OP (+10 to all stats... Why?)
Morgana has the best healing skills (Salvation, Mediarahan, Samarecarm, Me Patra), but Makoto's Mediarahan + items is just as good. Lowest damage output and most frail member, even his best armor sucks. He gets the Accuracy and Evasion debuff, but that becomes obsolete once Joker gets Debilitate, like Ann's (Ma)Tarunda. At least he's the best at evading attacks, he never has to use items to heal and Miracle Punch is somewhat decent.
To be honest, once I got a Persona with all 3 auto-buff abilities, I felt that a healer was no longer necessary, so my party was Ryuji / Ann / someone you haven't gotten yet against regular enemies and Ryuji / Ann / Morgana vs bosses, because I don't like Makoto as much and Joker was too OP. I used her though as my healer against the NG+ secret boss. Ryuji (highest damage, highest endurance, most HP, attack buff) / Ann (2nd highest damage output, Dormina for enemies that resist fire or have no weaknesses, Diarahan) / Makoto is definitely the best endgame party.
Bonus: Highest to lowest endgame damage in 2 turns (based on a topic I found on Gamefaqs):
PS - you'll have a lot of time during July and August to increase your stats. I was in the same boat and I still managed to max out the stats and the confidants. Just don't go into Mementos too often.
Talking Sock Big Daddy Boss
Posts : 9250 Joined : 2008-08-11 Age : 32 Location : Down Under
Subject: Re: Persona 5 Mon Jul 03, 2017 6:51 am
These True Love/Best Girl debates among fans are so pathetic. Clearly, the best option is to date all of them at the same time. Plebs.
Golden Boy Style Icon
Posts : 9301 Joined : 2008-07-31
Subject: Re: Persona 5 Mon Jul 03, 2017 6:22 pm
I picked Ann on my first play through. I honestly felt she was the canon choice because of the way Joker stared at her when they first met, while dramatic music was playing, and then again during the volleyball exhibition match. And because she is a hot model.
Sock wrote:
These True Love/Best Girl debates among fans are so pathetic. Clearly, the best option is to date all of them at the same time. Plebs.
Pfft. Best choice is not to date any of these weirdos and spend Valentine's Day with "Sakamoto Senpai".
Golden Boy Style Icon
Posts : 9301 Joined : 2008-07-31
Subject: Re: Persona 5 Wed Jul 05, 2017 8:11 pm
I've been praising the 3 Auto-Mas and Debilitate for a while now, so I figured I should probably tell you how to get them. You'll need to capture the Hope Diamond treasure demon, which carries the Auto-Mas, then fuse it into one of the 4 Riders, then fuse those into Trumpeter and level him up until he learns Debilitate. Hope Diamond is one of the most elusive Personas. I wasn't aware of its existence until I was close to completing the Compendium near the end of my second playthrough. It appears only in the latter half of the Mementos area (13th floor specifically) that is unlocked after the change of heart of the 6th Palace ruler and only after beating the 7th ruler. Capturing it normally would take a couple hours, but there is a much easier way.
First, you'll need to craft one of Morgana's items that increases the chances of treasure demons appearing, head into Mementos and activate it (its effect lasts until you leave Mementos). Go to the 13th floor and look around for a treasure demon. If you don't find any, leave the floor and come back. If you find one, start the battle; you may encounter Hope Diamond, Crystal Skull (itemize it for a great accessory) or Orlov (the treasure demon of the 7th palace). If it isn't the one you're looking for, run from the battle and find another enemy on the same floor, challenge it, then leave that battle. The treasure demon will have respawned. Keep repeating the process until you capture them all.
SimianWonder Simian D. Wonder
Posts : 6439 Joined : 2008-10-12 Age : 44 Location : Old People's home
Subject: Re: Persona 5 Sun Jul 09, 2017 7:56 pm
Another real-world week gone, and I'm making reasonable progress through the game. It's the start of September and the crew have just gotten back from their sun-kissed trip abroad
Spoiler:
.. followed immediately by a slightly out of left field hissy fit from Morgana, who went to the next palace alone and is receiving "mysterious" help. I say "mysterious", because unless you were completely inattentive, you can see exactly who it is that is helping him, which renders any sense of intrigue almost null and void, the how and the why being all that remain.
Anyway, back to the school trip, I was actually a bit disappointed that there was virtually no game play element during the entire trip, it was 99% just watching the story unfold and seeing Joker being a playa (I had four separate invites for the beach stroll, but went with Ann).
Finally got Fortune Confidant up to rank 7 and now I understand why she's so valuable. Being able to buy rank ups with other confidants without passing time is invaluable, even if they're expensive (again, 5000 yen a pop - ouch!) they allow you time to go and do something else, like raise stats or hit another confidant link. Speaking of stats, I'm not sure how I'm progressing relative to a typical play through; as above, I'm 13/14 September and have knowledge and charm at rank 4, the rest at rank 3. Can you guys remember roughly where you were at this point in the game?
Golden Boy Style Icon
Posts : 9301 Joined : 2008-07-31
Subject: Re: Persona 5 Mon Jul 10, 2017 9:37 am
No, but I checked my trophy history and I'd maxed out the social stats around the end of October or in early November. Have you been taking the Burger challenge? You'll gain +3 to every stat from the final one (only the first time though, subsequent attempts grant +3 to Guts only). Also, fix the PC for a Proficiency bonus.
Talking Sock Big Daddy Boss
Posts : 9250 Joined : 2008-08-11 Age : 32 Location : Down Under
Subject: Re: Persona 5 Mon Jul 10, 2017 10:21 am
SimianWonder wrote:
Anyway, back to the school trip, I was actually a bit disappointed that there was virtually no game play element during the entire trip, it was 99% just watching the story unfold and seeing Joker being a playa (I had four separate invites for the beach stroll, but went with Ann).
Now you see what I mean about story overtaking gameplay in some PS2-PS4 era RPGs? I didn't look forward to the post-dungeon experiences of P5 much, given that they were usually so padded with scenes and had very little interactivity involved. Didn't mind the school trip part a whole lot though. There's at least a change of scenery n' stuff.
Quote :
I'm not sure how I'm progressing relative to a typical play through; as above, I'm 13/14 September and have knowledge and charm at rank 4, the rest at rank 3. Can you guys remember roughly where you were at this point in the game?
I think I was around the same ballpark. I didn't use the internet for much stuff on my playthrough other than certain enemy locations for specific persona fusions.
Spoiler:
I had to learn about the Temperance confidant screw over the hard way.
And boy, tackling Palace 7 in only two visits (and even then, the first visit only had a little bit of stuff done, with the second taking up most of the work) just barely battle-ready for what was to come near the end sure was fun. Isn't it typical THAT asshole had to be even more of a pain? I got him, though. Him and that Persona of his...
Last edited by Sock on Mon Jul 10, 2017 7:20 pm; edited 1 time in total
SimianWonder Simian D. Wonder
Posts : 6439 Joined : 2008-10-12 Age : 44 Location : Old People's home
Subject: Re: Persona 5 Mon Jul 10, 2017 6:14 pm
I've actually got a few maxed confidants already, but I may sacrifice a couple of them in order to work on my social stats with the aim of doing a 100% NG+ run. I do find myself running out of money pretty frequently though; without exploiting the mementos trick you mentioned earlier, Chou, is there any reliable way to generate decent income?
Golden Boy Style Icon
Posts : 9301 Joined : 2008-07-31
Subject: Re: Persona 5 Mon Jul 10, 2017 7:07 pm
- There is a way to exploit the lottery, but I've no idea how it works. - You can ask a defeated enemy for money during the hold-up (Sun Confidant). - You can get bonus money after successfully ambushing the Shadows (Star Confidant). - Use the fortune teller's ability. - Sell stuff to Iwai.
You'd just go for the Mementos' trick, as it is easily the most efficient way and you'll need millions to complete the compendium, create the best equipment and make some decent Personas.
Golden Boy Style Icon
Posts : 9301 Joined : 2008-07-31
Subject: Re: Persona 5 Mon Jul 10, 2017 7:54 pm
Here's how to do it:
1. get an Onmoraki (https://chinhodado.github.io/persona5_calculator/#/persona/Onmoraki ) 2. level it up to learn Pulinpa and Confuse Boost 3. fuse it with Rakshasa for Sandman and carry other those skills 4.level it up via gallows manipulating its stat gains (you want Luck to be the only stat highlighted, if it isn't return to the previous menu and try again) 5. go to Mementos and fight a boss that can be confused (http://megamitensei.wikia.com/wiki/Mementos) [6. remove everyone from your party to save time from skipping their turns]
At ~70 luck, I was getting over 100k per turn.
P.S. even if you don't want to use the money exploit until your 2nd playthrough, you should create the persona now and use the gallows once everyday to increase its luck. I'm sure Sock took advantage of the Pulinpa exploit too; he is a known cheater!
Talking Sock Big Daddy Boss
Posts : 9250 Joined : 2008-08-11 Age : 32 Location : Down Under
Subject: Re: Persona 5 Mon Jul 10, 2017 8:44 pm
No, I took the long way around and had to cast that ability that made them more susceptible to status effect moves first an-- I mean. I don't know what you're talking about.
SimianWonder Simian D. Wonder
Posts : 6439 Joined : 2008-10-12 Age : 44 Location : Old People's home
Subject: Re: Persona 5 Sat Jul 15, 2017 3:34 pm
Okay, quick update with some spoiler-y musings.
I'm now at the end of October and
Spoiler:
Makoto has deduced from Futaba's findings that the Phantom Thieves have been being manipulated into taking out the ruler of the fifth palace. Thing is, there have been a couple of big hints of where things are heading.
Please, don't confirm or dent any of the following speculation, I'm just trying to think things through as logically as I can.
So, there's a traitor amongst the thieves. We've known that from the first few minutes of the game (and no, I haven't forgotten, even sixty hours later!) and there are only two possibilities I can see. First up, and least likely, is Haru. She's been far too nice about the fact that her father died as a result of the Thieves' actions. Second, and most likely culprit, is Akechi. Why A few reasons, some of which are very meta so I'm sure Chou shall approve of the deduction, even if it is incorrect!
1) Akechi is on the steelbook case, meaning he very likely becomes a Phantom Thief at some point. 2) However, he has no portrait on the exterior of the "Take your Heart" edition box. 3) Neither does he feature with the rest of the Phantom Thieves in the "Art of Persona" book. He's listed as "extra characters", just like Sae 4) There have been several parallels to the reveal of the killer in P4, notably several scenes in which Akechi is visible - even only partially in some cases - in the background, including times where the Thieves enter the metaverse on at least a couple of occasions. He didn't looked shocked or flustered by any of it at any time.
Ergo, he'll join the Thieves under false pretences only to be revealed as the traitor at some point. Yes, it's very meta and based on what could be viewed as circumstantial evidence, but there's no way all those things together can be mere coincidence. It'll be interesting to see how close to the mark I am.
As for the hows and whys though? I've got no idea. Presumably he's working for someone else.
Talking Sock Big Daddy Boss
Posts : 9250 Joined : 2008-08-11 Age : 32 Location : Down Under
Subject: Re: Persona 5 Sat Jul 15, 2017 3:57 pm
Save for later.
Spoiler:
Golden Boy Style Icon
Posts : 9301 Joined : 2008-07-31
Subject: Re: Persona 5 Sat Jul 15, 2017 4:42 pm
Next Palace (6th) = Best Palace Whims of Fate is my favourite Persona song.
Last edited by Golden Boy on Sat Jul 15, 2017 4:52 pm; edited 1 time in total
SimianWonder Simian D. Wonder
Posts : 6439 Joined : 2008-10-12 Age : 44 Location : Old People's home
Subject: Re: Persona 5 Sat Jul 15, 2017 4:52 pm
Well, fai to say I may have been wrong...
Spoiler:
Goro was invited to the school fayre thing, and admitted he's known who the Thieves were for the last month. Additionally, he's a persona user now as well, and was attacked by the real murderer.
Now, this may be a lie, but if he was the killer and knew who the Thieves were, he would surely have just outed us by now? Or worse, killed us.
Oh, and Sojiro found Futaba's calling card. Busted.
Golden Boy Style Icon
Posts : 9301 Joined : 2008-07-31
Subject: Re: Persona 5 Sat Jul 15, 2017 6:00 pm
There was a pretty obvious hint about the traitor's identity, but you probably missed it. I wish I hadn't noticed it either, so I could have speculated about the traitor too. Also, if you fail to complete a Palace before the deadline, Joker will be arrested and the traitor shows up in a cutscene (you don't see the face, but you can easily recognise the voice). I think the identities of the Phantom Thieves' enemies are not supposed to be this game's plot twist.
SimianWonder Simian D. Wonder
Posts : 6439 Joined : 2008-10-12 Age : 44 Location : Old People's home
Subject: Re: Persona 5 Sat Jul 15, 2017 7:08 pm
I'm guessing there'll be twists in store yet; after all, Joker gets caught in the casino. We know this.
Spoiler:
So, has Sae had a change of heart? Is this all an elaborate ruse? There have been a couple of scenes recently where the background has gone a bit fuzzy, Sae alluding to the fact that Joker may still be drugged, only it has happened in his memories as well.