Should I hate Nostalgia Critic for this or indulge it?

I'll be watching the Tick, cause that guy talked about it is one of his top 11 nostalgic cartoons and showed "SPOOOOOON"

Should you hate him for mentioning a good cartoon? No. You should hate him for his reviews being nothing but screeching and yelling about how bad something is.

I love his review of the other Titanic animated feature

Stop tryng to be alternative Baal.

Have you seen his LP Moose? Watch that and tell me I"m not right.

Oh, his LP was shit. Couldn't watch it.

Nostalgia Critic is shit and if you like him you should feel bad.

Afro Sergeant Baal wrote:

Have you seen his LP Moose? Watch that and tell me I"m not right.

Retsupurae did a riff on it.

http://blip.tv/slowbeef/retsupurae-vs-the-nostalgia-critic-5535142

Yes I saw it, it's great.

Nostalgia Critic often bitches about certain films being unrealistic when they're not supposed to be.

Zero wrote:

Nostalgia Critic often bitches about certain films being unrealistic when they're not supposed to be.

Well then that would be a valid complaint, yes?

A_Nonny_Moose wrote:

Zero wrote:

Nostalgia Critic often bitches about certain films being unrealistic when they're not supposed to be.

Well then that would be a valid complaint, yes?

I think he means that he complains about it when the movie is not supposed to be realistic.

Rockstar_Leviathan wrote:

A_Nonny_Moose wrote:

Zero wrote:

Nostalgia Critic often bitches about certain films being unrealistic when they're not supposed to be.

Well then that would be a valid complaint, yes?

I think he means that he complains about it when the movie is not supposed to be realistic.

Correct. When a movie goes for unrealistic things and over exaggerations on purpose, Nostalgia Critic complains that it's not realistic. But you should judge a film based on its aim. Now obviously there's a point where you'd draw the line with the unrealism, but NC is usually very nitpicky with his complaints.

If I remember correctly he did the exact same thing with Last Action Hero where the movie was supposed to be a parody of over the top action flicks and then he completely misses the point.

Last Action Hero was a horrible movie.

I'm not saying it's not.

Then he's completely in the right to bitch about it for 20 minutes.

Not really.

Last Action Hero is alright.

Funny cartoon, I'll indulge myself with it, at least for a while

You never watched The Tick as a kid? You'll love it!


P.S: The Nostalgia Critic sucks.

The Iron Fjord wrote:

You never watched The Tick as a kid? You'll love it!

Ne'er watched it before, love it now

Quote :

P.S: The Nostalgia Critic sucks.

I kept telling that to my bro, he keeps watching his shit

Anyone else seen his Good Son "review". I think it's his best. lol

Rockstar_Leviathan wrote:

Anyone else seen his Good Son "review". I think it's his best. lol

I did rewatch it recently, at it was still pretty good. His best was the Sonic Cartoon one, though I didn't like the way he bashed the first Sonic cartoon, I like that one!

His best video was the PSA one. No stupid faces(aside from a few near the end, but they were all short shots and aren't that cringe-worthy), no obnoxious screaming, decent jokes that were quick and snappy, and the adverts he was reviewing were all hilariously stupid.

It's one of the few videos where he's not acting pissed off over genuinely bad things.